Top 25 Highest-Rated Players in MLB The Show 25

Select Language:

In baseball, with only nine defensive positions, the impact of a single talented player can be enormous for any team. Some positions hold more influence than others, especially since they are involved in gameplay more frequently in MLB The Show 25. Therefore, it’s essential to identify the top-ranked players in the game.

A prime example of a vital position is that of the pitcher. Adding one of the best pitchers from MLB The Show 25 to your roster is always a significant advantage, as players will spend more time controlling them compared to others. Moreover, you will want top-tier hitters on your team to ensure that your offense is as robust as your defense. Fortunately, MLB The Show 25 features an impressive array of elite players, and more than half of the league’s teams include at least one of them.

Top-Rated Players in MLB The Show 25

Highest Overall Ratings: 99 is the Maximum

When examining the top-ranked players in MLB The Show 25, a diverse lineup of positions stands out. Shohei Ohtani, who excels as both a starting pitcher and an outstanding hitter, is a phenomenal choice for any Diamond Dynasty lineup. Below is a complete list of the highest-rated players in MLB The Show 25, along with their stats and positions:

Player ADVERTISEMENT	Rating	Position
Shohei Ohtani	99	Starting Pitcher/Designated Hitter
Juan Soto	99	Outfield
Aaron Judge	99	Outfield
Mike Trout	99	Outfield
Ketel Marte	96	Second Base
Bobby Witt Jr.	96	Shortstop
Mookie Betts	95	Shortstop
Fransico Lindor	95	Shortstop
Bryce Harper	95	First Base
José Ramírez	95	Third Base
Chris Sale	94	Starting Pitcher
Gunnar Henderson	94	Shortstop
Tarik Skubal	94	Starting Pitcher
Fernando Tatis	93	Outfield
Ronald Acuña Jr.	93	Outfield
Kyler Tucker	93	Outfield
Elly De La Cruz	93	Shortstop
Paul Skenes	93	Starting Pitcher
Corey Seager	93	Shortstop
Yordan Alvarez	92	Outfield
Tyler Glasnow	91	Starting Pitcher
Emmanuel Clase	91	Relief Pitcher
Freddie Freeman	90	First Base
Zach Wheeler	90	Starting Pitcher
Trea Turner	90	Shortstop

While Ohtani is an obvious standout, there are other exceptional pitchers in MLB The Show 25 worth noticing. Both Tarik Skubal and Chris Sale had impressive seasons in 2024, ranking first and second, respectively, for the most strikeouts that year. Emmanuel Clase also deserves attention; he is the only relief pitcher in the top 25 players of the game.

MLB The Show 25 Player Ratings: Every Player With A 99 OVR

Some of MLB The Show 25’s player ratings have been released, and the players who have achieved the maximum 99 OVR might surprise you.

There is also a strong roster of powerful hitters found among the top-rated players in MLB The Show 25. Aaron Judge posted an impressive .322 batting average during the 2024 season over 559 at-bats, which is significantly higher than his career average. It appears that MLB The Show 25 anticipates another strong performance from him this year. While Juan Soto didn’t reach the same heights statistically as Judge last season, he has been excelling in Spring Training, which could clarify his high rating in MLB The Show.

Having a solid shortstop like Gunnar Henderson might not make him one of the top hitters in the game, but his abilities are crucial for throwing out players attempting to advance on the bases.

While hitting and pitching are the two most active roles you’ll play in MLB The Show 25, it’s crucial to pay attention to the other defensive positions. A player like Gunnar Henderson, while not among the top hitters, can significantly impact the game. Effective defenses can prevent players from advancing on the bases, while reliable statistics become increasingly vital for positions that require less direct control, as players have fewer opportunities to compensate for lower stats.

Teams with Top Players

Not All MLB Teams Have Top Players, and Some Have Multiple

A team holds up a World Series banner in MLB The Show 25 Franchise Mode

18 out of 30 MLB teams have players among the top-ranked in MLB The Show 25. While this represents a majority of the league, it’s disappointing for fans of teams like the Chicago White Sox not to see any representation (something I expected). Some teams, however, feature multiple players in the top 25, reflecting their performance throughout the 2024 MLB season.

Here are the teams with the top-rated players in MLB The Show 25:

LA Dodgers
New York Mets
New York Yankees
LA Angels
Arizona Diamondbacks
Kansas City Royals
Washington Nationals
Cleveland Guardians
Atlanta Braves
Baltimore Orioles
Detroit Tigers
San Diego Padres
Chicago Cubs
Cincinnati Reds
Pittsburgh Pirates
Texas Rangers
Houston Astros
Philadelphia Phillies

Unsurprisingly, the LA Dodgers, who clinched the 2024 World Series, boast the most players on this top list, with four players making the top 25. This includes the highest-ranked player, Shohei Ohtani. The New York Mets also feature two players in the top 25, including Juan Soto, the second-highest rated player, and Fransico Lindor. Interestingly, while the New York Yankees were prominent contenders in the 2024 World Series, they only have one representative on the list: Aaron Judge, one of only three players rated 99 overall.

Understanding which teams have the most high-ranking players is useful when selecting one for MLB The Show 25‘s Franchise mode. Of course, if you’re looking for a greater challenge, you may choose to avoid dominant teams like the Dodgers or Mets by opting to play with less effective players. Being aware of the top-ranked individuals in MLB The Show 25 is also valuable for assembling your Diamond Dynasty team, as you work towards forming a custom roster that can achieve that coveted 99 overall ranking.