Select Language:
“Outer Worlds 2” presents players with many choices, but one of the most memorable is the decision at Alexandra Monastery involving hostages. There, the fanatic Seer Wiley offers a tough choice: solve a puzzle to save some hostages or ignore the puzzle and head straight ahead, choosing between two doors labeled “Betray Your Values” and “Be A Hero.” You can talk with your team before deciding, but your companions may give conflicting advice based on their views.
While rescuing the hostages seems like the morally right thing to do, the consequences can be unsettling. It could be a trick, or saving them might lead to more casualties later. Still, the situation isn’t as complicated as it might seem at first glance.
### What Happens If You Save the Hostages
Choosing to save the hostages leads you to a puzzle involving a large ball rolling down a ramp. To get the ball to the bottom, you’ll need to eliminate enemies and then manipulate switches and obstacles to guide the ball. The timing isn’t critical; handle each step one at a time, letting the ball pass before moving to the next.
Steps include:
– Going upstairs to press a switch near the ball
– Activating other switches until the ball passes each barrier
– Shooting crates downstairs to clear the path
– Flipping switches to direct the ball correctly
– Raising the ball with switches so it reaches its destination
Afterward, you get a special key card. Use it at the machine with the hostages, and decide whether to save or kill them. Saving them rewards you with a +3 reputation with the Order and other benefits. Killing them might seem appealing for certain playstyles, but it usually offers fewer long-term advantages.
Rescuing the hostages also increases your reputation and gives you useful items, plus it can help you in future conversations with NPCs. However, Wiley takes advantage of your delay to send crucial signals to de Vries, which makes your next mission harder because de Vries will have fewer forces.
### What Happens If You Leave the Hostages
If you choose to ignore the puzzle and leave the hostages behind by going through the “Betray Your Values” door, Wiley will follow through on his threat but not immediately. You can retreat and solve the puzzle later if you change your mind.
If Wiley finishes his plan, the hostages will die, costing you 3 reputation points with the Order. While this might make your next mission easier because de Vries will have fewer mechanical enemies, it’s a morally darker choice that impacts your standing.
### Why You Should Save the Hostages
Overall, saving the hostages is the stronger choice. Morally, it’s the right thing, and it offers more benefits over time. Even from a gameplay perspective, gaining goodwill with the Order can be advantageous for future missions.
For players looking to avoid combat, intentionally letting the hostages die can make things easier right now, especially for characters built around efficiency or avoiding fights. But the decision to save them is generally the smarter move, with more long-term rewards. Choosing to solve the puzzle and then kill the hostages, while a dark option, doesn’t provide any benefit and isn’t recommended.
In summary, saving the hostages at Alexandra Monastery is an easy decision that pays off in both story and gameplay. It helps you build reputation, potentially influences future interactions, and makes your overall journey smoother.
ChatGPT
Perplexity
Gemini AI
Grok AI
